1968: Envisioning Bernal Heights as a Much Prettier Place

BernalDesignElements.1968

This map comes to us via the good offices of the esteemed Eric Fisher. It shows what a group of city planners saw in 1968, when they evaluated Bernal Heights as an urban canvas in need of some serious beautification.

This wasn’t some grandiose urban-renewal effort, like those crazy 1940s visions of turning Bernal’s stretch of Mission Street into an elevated superhighway.  Quite the opposite: In 1968′s “Bernal Heights Improvement Program” (PDF here), the goal was to use Bernal to improve Bernal; to evaluate and exploit the geographic realities of Bernal Heights to offset the gathering forces of deterioration and “economic decline:”

BernalReport.1968

So with that as the context, it’s fascinating to see what those planners saw when they looked at Bernal Heights as set of assets and opportunities — at a time when Bernal’s streets were a little rougher around the edges and Bernal Hill was still just a feral, open space.

The “Design Elements” map notes the features that make Bernal feel like Bernal; the “physical elements that give definition and identity to Bernal Heights.” It identifies existing resources. It respects the topography. It celebrates great views. It highlights open spaces. It seeks to nurture interesting clusters and sub-corridors.

Those observations were distilled into a separate “Bernal Improvement Plan” map:

Bernal.ImprovementPlan.1968

Basically, the proposed plan advocates paving the last of Bernal’s dirt streets, building a few landscaped stairways, turning Bernal Hill into a proper park, creating a few other mini-parks, and planting lost and lots of trees

If all this sounds kind of familiar and ho-hum, it’s because that’s pretty much what we’ve spent the last 45 years doing here in Bernal Heights. So hats off to those clever planners in 1968. From the vantage point of 2013, we can now say that their vision looks pretty great today.

PHOTOS: Maps via Eric Fischer

About these ads
This entry was posted in Geography, History. Bookmark the permalink.

17 Responses to 1968: Envisioning Bernal Heights as a Much Prettier Place

  1. jack says:

    I take offense that “the southerly and easterly views are more confused and discordant”! :-)

  2. S says:

    really wish they were able to enhance the Alemany Farmer’s Market and bury the overhead wires…Maybe in 2013? :-)

  3. Judge Crater says:

    Likewise. I really don’t understand why the under grounding plan was so un-comprehensive, but I have been told many times that more under grounding is one of those things that just isn’t going to happen. Maybe our dynamic supervisor will take the lead and make it happen!

  4. Brandon says:

    I happen to live on a street with buried utilities, and it is much nicer.

    The cost of burying lines is exorbitant, though, and even worse in established neighborhoods. Who will pay for it? My in-laws in the LA area recently went through the process, and it drove a wedge between neighbors who wanted to get rid of the poles and wires and had the money to pay for it and the neighbors (many on fixed incomes) who would struggle to pay the levied fee.

  5. vizetelly says:

    The utilities were finally under-grounded on Powhattan and the surrounding blocks about four years back. It’s a ginormous job and each house that is connected is a unique situation that must be dealt with usually to the tune of $1K, especially if you don’t want the pipes crawling up the front of your house. At the same time, they also ‘beautified’ the street for a few blocks. The new stairways from all the north-south streets leading to the south side of the hill were also done in the last five years. Powhattan from Gates to Nevada was paved about 8-9 years back.

    It is interesting that most of those things were on the ‘master-plan’ and only took 40-50 years. The beautiful view of San Bruno Mountain from the Comfy Couch* definitely is improved without wires.

    * (note to nomenclature committee) SOuth-FAcing Bernal Hill (SOFA) = Comfy Couch ‘micro-neighborhood’ designation. Proposed boundaries: North – Bernal Hill Park/Esmeralda Avenue, East – Franconia Avenue, South – Cortland, West – TBD (Gates/Andover/Bocana?)

    • When utilities on my block were undergrounded, I thought they’d finally get rid of the ugly cable TV splitter mounted on the front of my apartment building. It’s in a little box with a door that won’t close because there are too many wires. There was never enough signal, and whichever one of the four units that had complained most recently would briefly get an acceptable signal, while somebody else got moved to a marginal tap. So what happened when they brought cable in underground? They pulled it up the back of the building, over the roof, and connected it tot the same splitter! Shaking my head…

  6. davidkaye says:

    I never liked the idea of paving the remaining dirt streets in Bernal. When Franconia was finally paved it was because “it would make it easier for firetrucks to get access”, an odd comment given that Franconia existed just fine as a dirt road for 100 years with no fire problems. I say that newcomers owe it to their new community to respect the will of those who were already there and not screw things up. South of Market is a perfect example of newcomers who moved into the junk condos (aka “live/work lofts”) and then began to complain about noise from the bars and the machine shops, forcing many of them to closer or spend tens of thousands of dollars on soundproofing — even though those businesses had been there for decades.

  7. I’m not sure what they’ve done to Ogden st or in what shape it was before that plan, but it’s currently quite messy. I kind of like the idea of turning most of it into mini-parks.

  8. davidkaye says:

    I guess few people realize that lots of antennas have already been removed from the tower at the top of the hill. AT&T used to have inter-city TV relays with big “horn” antennas. Those all disappeared a couple years ago, so now the site doesn’t look very busy at all.

  9. bernalcoyete says:

    How about making the top of the Hill into a more friendly place where people can come together to watch stars, eat lunch etc. Wind chimes, art work, tables, etc. Take don the fence open iup the top of bernal to the people!!!!!!

  10. Todd_Lappin says:

    That sounds good, but let’s leave the tower, because many of us love it dearly.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s